STUDIA THEOLOGIA CATHOLICA LATINA 		 
REVIEWS
    
         
   
         
  PEER REVIEW  
           
 

All papers are reviewed independently by two peer reviewers. The reviewers fill in due time a standard evaluation form. The reviewers’ suggestions or requests for modifications are anonymously communicated to the authors, together with the decision of the editorial board on the publication of the paper.

  
           
           
 

Referee Report Form

 

Paper Identification

Title:

 

Author Name:

 

 

Referee Info

Name:

 

Institute:

 

Phone:

 

Email:

 

Expertise area:

 

Judgement   (5 Excellent;  4 Good;  3 Average;  2 Below Average;  1 Poor)


Relevance to the field of religion (theology): 

 

Originality:

 

Importance, significance and value of contribution:

 

Logical and formal correctness:

 

Proper crediting/citing of previous literature:

 

Clarity, structure and style of presentation:

 

Grammar/spelling:

 

 
Recommendation (Accept/Revise/Reject):

 

Comments to the editor (Confidential)

 

 

 

Comments to the author