The STUDIA UNIVERSITATIS BABEŞ-BOLYAI issue article summary

The summary of the selected article appears at the bottom of the page. In order to get back to the contents of the issue this article belongs to you have to access the link from the title. In order to see all the articles of the archive which have as author/co-author one of the authors mentioned below, you have to access the link from the author's name.

 
       
         
    STUDIA THEOLOGIA%20CATHOLICA - Issue no. 1 / 2010  
         
  Article:   AN UPHEAVAL IN THE ECCLESIOLOGY OF THE 18TH CENTURY, WHICH TURNED THE LATINS AND GREEKS INTO TWO DIFFERENT CONFESSIONS ACCUSING EACH OTHER OF ERROR IN FAITH AND NAMING THEMSELVES „CATHOLICS” AND „ORTHODOX” RESPECTIVELY / EIN UMSTURZ IN DER EKKLESIOLOGIE DES 18. JAHRHUNDERTS, DER LATEINER UND GRIECHEN ZU ZWEI KONFESSIONEN MACHTE, WELCHE SICH GEGENSEITIG DES IRRTUMS IM GLAUBEN BESCHULDIGEN UND SICH SEITHER „KATHOLIKEN” BZW. „ORTHODOXE” NENNEN.

Authors:  ERNST CHRISTOPH SUTTNER.
 
       
         
  Abstract:   An upheaval in the ecclesiology of the 18th century, which turned the Latins and Greeks into two different confessions accusing each other of error in faith and naming themselves „Catholics” and „Orthodox” respectively. At the council of Ferrara – Florence (1438–9), the Western and Eastern Churches, although formally separated, mutually respected their ecclesiastic dignity, and accepted that the unity of the Church can exist through diversity of tradition. This perspective has changed in time, especially after the council of Trient (1545–63). By clarifying its dogma towards the Protestant theology, Catholicism conceived ecclesiastic unity as uniformity and considered – in strong opposition with the Florentine opinion – any community outside the Roman obedience as heretic or suspect of heresy. In the same period, the Greek Church under Ottoman rule reached a period of stability, after the difficulties of the time of Kyrillos Lukaris (1572–1638) and due to the decline of the Empire. It was the moment when she could revise her theology and the result was the conception that the Orthodox Church is the only keeper of the unaltered treasure of the Revelation. Those two positions are best reflected in two documents of the period: the 1729 decree of the Congregation for the Propagation of the Faith and the synodal decision of the Constantinopolitan Patriarchy of 1755. These documents are based on the ecclesiology of the respective Churches and deny both the ecclesiality of the other and the capability of validly administrating the Sacraments. From these points of view, the possibility for each of the two great Christian Churches to assure the salvation of their members seems to be obliterated. Some of these difficulties are still to be overcome.

KEYWORDS: Church unity, Council of Florence, Council of Trient, Catholic ecclesiology, Orhtodox ecclesiology, recognition of Sacraments. 

 
         
     
         
         
      Back to previous page