The STUDIA UNIVERSITATIS BABEŞ-BOLYAI issue article summary

The summary of the selected article appears at the bottom of the page. In order to get back to the contents of the issue this article belongs to you have to access the link from the title. In order to see all the articles of the archive which have as author/co-author one of the authors mentioned below, you have to access the link from the author's name.

 
       
         
    STUDIA HISTORIA - Issue no. 2 / 2021  
         
  Article:   CORRECTION OF SOME ERRORS IN THE SCIENTIFIC EDITIONS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC HISTORY (1705) BY DIMITRIE CANTEMIR. THE PANAITESCU-VERDEŞ EDITION (1965) / CORRECTION DE QUELQUES ERREURS DANS LES EDITIONS SCIENTIFIQUES DE L’HISTOIRE HIÉROGLYPHIQUE (1705) PAR DIMITRIE CANTEMIR. L’EDITION PANAITESCU-VERDEŞ (1965).

Authors:  ŞTEFAN ŞUTEU.
 
       
         
  Abstract:  DOI: 10.24193/subbhist.2021.2.01

Article history: Received 3.11.2021; Revised 10.12.2021;
Accepted 28.12.2021; Available online 13.04.2022.
pp. 3-16

VIEW PDF

FULL PDF

Abstract: Correction of some errors in the scientific editions of The Hieroglyphic History (1705) by Dimitrie Cantemir. The Panaitescu-Verdeş edition (1965). The Hieroglyphic History, written by Dimitrie Cantemir in 1705, is considered the first Romanian (historical) novel. Beyond the veil of allegory, the exotic topos and animal-related fantasy, the historical events between 1685-1705 are revealed through characteristic deciphering, which can represent valuable data for a historian. The work, first published in 1883, then in 1927 and 1957 in a few non-scientific editions, was finally republished in 1965 in a scientific edition elaborated by P.P. Panaitescu and Ion Verdeş. This particular 1965 edition is of very high historical value, but it also has a number of lacunae, especially in the field of theology. The editors donʼt reference certain biblical quotes, they hint at certain psychological ideas when mentioning quotes that are clearly extracted from the Bible, they ignore the biblical source, which was the very foundation of Cantemirʼs maxims, they overlook the study of certain toponyms with biblical origins (Euphrates, Tarshish, Babylon etc.) and donʼt realize that some of his ideas are of biblical origin (for example: the cyclical evolution of things, free will). Furthermore, they donʼt distinguish certain elements of Christian iconography from their biblical counterparts, leading to confusion (according to the editors, Saint Veronicaʼs Veil is attributed to Magdalene!). For all this, attention, thoroughness, knowledge of biblical sources and familiarity with Romanian and European biblical tradition are required. An edition of The Hieroglyphic History which envelopes historical, philological, but also theological and, last but not least, philosophical notes and commentaries is expected in the future.

Keywords: Dimitrie Cantemir, The Hieroglyphic History, Panaitescu, Verdeş, theology, cyclical evolution, Menander, The Apostle Paul, Saint Veronicaʼs Veil
 
         
     
         
         
      Back to previous page